Failing to compiler from master head

[madwax]

Issue

build of master failed.
I have just setup a Ubuntu 24.04 machine, cloned master (9857dcf) and tried to build using cmake as outline in the instructions.

I get the following errors:

In file included from /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/include/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.hpp:15,
from /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/src/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.cpp:1:
In member function ‘void sol::stack::field_getter<T, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[23]; T = char [23]; bool global = false; bool raw = false; = void]’,
inlined from ‘void sol::stack::get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; Key = const char (&)[23]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12092:62,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[23]; T = char [23]; P = int; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16329:21,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[15]; T = char [15]; P = int; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16323:9,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; C = int; Key = const char (&)[15]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12112:78,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_deep_optional(int&, int, Key&&, Keys&& ...) const [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; sol::detail::insert_mode mode = sol::detail::none; T = sol::optional; Key = const char (&)[15]; Keys = {}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25627:62,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_single(int, Keys&& ...) const [with bool raw = false; Ret = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[15]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25533:83,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get(Keys&& ...) const [with T = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[15]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25860:40,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::tuple_get(std::index_sequence<_Ind ...>) const & [with T = sol::optional; long unsigned int ...I = {0}; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[15]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24742:39,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::get() const & [with T = sol::optional; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[15]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24847:23,
inlined from ‘sol::proxy_base< >::operator T() const [with T = sol::optional; typename std::enable_if<sol::meta::all<std::integral_constant<bool, (! std::integral_constant<bool, ((((((is_string_literal_array_of_v<T, char> || is_same_v<T, const char*>) || is_same_v<T, char>) || is_string_of_v<T, char>) || is_same_v<T, std::initializer_list >) || is_string_view_of_v<T, char>) || is_null_pointer_v)>::value)>, sol::is_proxy_primitive<typename std::remove_cv<typename std::remove_reference<Iter>::type>::type> >::value, sol::meta::enable_t>::type = sol::meta::enable_t::; Super = sol::table_proxy<sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&, std::tuple<const char (&)[15]> >]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16973:32,
inlined from ‘osrm::extractor::Sol2ScriptingEnvironment::InitContext(osrm::extractor::LuaScriptingContext&)::<lambda()>’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/src/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.cpp:644:85:
/home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16152:49: error: array subscript ‘const char [23][0]’ is partly outside array bounds of ‘const char [15]’ [-Werror=array-bounds=]
16152 | lua_getfield(L, tableindex, &key[0]);
| ^~~~~~~~~~~~
In member function ‘void sol::stack::field_getter<T, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[30]; T = char [30]; bool global = false; bool raw = false; = void]’,
inlined from ‘void sol::stack::get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; Key = const char (&)[30]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12092:62,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[30]; T = char [30]; P = bool; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16329:21,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[18]; T = char [18]; P = bool; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16323:9,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; C = bool; Key = const char (&)[18]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12112:78,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_deep_optional(int&, int, Key&&, Keys&& ...) const [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; sol::detail::insert_mode mode = sol::detail::none; T = sol::optional; Key = const char (&)[18]; Keys = {}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25627:62,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_single(int, Keys&& ...) const [with bool raw = false; Ret = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[18]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25533:83,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get(Keys&& ...) const [with T = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[18]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25860:40,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::tuple_get(std::index_sequence<_Ind ...>) const & [with T = sol::optional; long unsigned int ...I = {0}; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[18]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24742:39,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::get() const & [with T = sol::optional; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[18]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24847:23,
inlined from ‘sol::proxy_base< >::operator T() const [with T = sol::optional; typename std::enable_if<sol::meta::all<std::integral_constant<bool, (! std::integral_constant<bool, ((((((is_string_literal_array_of_v<T, char> || is_same_v<T, const char*>) || is_same_v<T, char>) || is_string_of_v<T, char>) || is_same_v<T, std::initializer_list >) || is_string_view_of_v<T, char>) || is_null_pointer_v)>::value)>, sol::is_proxy_primitive<typename std::remove_cv<typename std::remove_reference<Iter>::type>::type> >::value, sol::meta::enable_t>::type = sol::meta::enable_t::; Super = sol::table_proxy<sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&, std::tuple<const char (&)[18]> >]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16973:32,
inlined from ‘osrm::extractor::Sol2ScriptingEnvironment::InitContext(osrm::extractor::LuaScriptingContext&)::<lambda()>’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/src/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.cpp:663:83:
/home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16152:49: error: array subscript ‘const char [30][0]’ is partly outside array bounds of ‘const char [18]’ [-Werror=array-bounds=]
16152 | lua_getfield(L, tableindex, &key[0]);
| ^~~~~~~~~~~~
In member function ‘void sol::stack::field_getter<T, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[23]; T = char [23]; bool global = false; bool raw = false; = void]’,
inlined from ‘void sol::stack::get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; Key = const char (&)[23]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12092:62,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[23]; T = char [23]; P = int; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16329:21,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[17]; T = char [17]; P = unsigned int; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16323:9,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; C = unsigned int; Key = const char (&)[17]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12112:78,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_deep_optional(int&, int, Key&&, Keys&& ...) const [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; sol::detail::insert_mode mode = sol::detail::none; T = sol::optional; Key = const char (&)[17]; Keys = {}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25627:62,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_single(int, Keys&& ...) const [with bool raw = false; Ret = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[17]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25533:83,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get(Keys&& ...) const [with T = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[17]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25860:40,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::tuple_get(std::index_sequence<_Ind ...>) const & [with T = sol::optional; long unsigned int ...I = {0}; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[17]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24742:39,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::get() const & [with T = sol::optional; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[17]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24847:23,
inlined from ‘sol::proxy_base< >::operator T() const [with T = sol::optional; typename std::enable_if<sol::meta::all<std::integral_constant<bool, (! std::integral_constant<bool, ((((((is_string_literal_array_of_v<T, char> || is_same_v<T, const char*>) || is_same_v<T, char>) || is_string_of_v<T, char>) || is_same_v<T, std::initializer_list >) || is_string_view_of_v<T, char>) || is_null_pointer_v)>::value)>, sol::is_proxy_primitive<typename std::remove_cv<typename std::remove_reference<Iter>::type>::type> >::value, sol::meta::enable_t>::type = sol::meta::enable_t::; Super = sol::table_proxy<sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&, std::tuple<const char (&)[17]> >]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16973:32,
inlined from ‘osrm::extractor::Sol2ScriptingEnvironment::InitContext(osrm::extractor::LuaScriptingContext&)::<lambda()>’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/src/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.cpp:667:85:
/home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16152:49: error: array subscript ‘const char [23][0]’ is partly outside array bounds of ‘const char [17]’ [-Werror=array-bounds=]
16152 | lua_getfield(L, tableindex, &key[0]);
| ^~~~~~~~~~~~
In member function ‘void sol::stack::field_getter<T, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[30]; T = char [30]; bool global = false; bool raw = false; = void]’,
inlined from ‘void sol::stack::get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; Key = const char (&)[30]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12092:62,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[30]; T = char [30]; P = bool; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16329:21,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_field_getter<T, P, global, raw, >::get(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with Key = const char (&)[18]; T = char [18]; P = bool; bool b = false; bool raw = false; = void]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16323:9,
inlined from ‘sol::stack::probe sol::stack::probe_get_field(lua_State*, Key&&, int) [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; C = bool; Key = const char (&)[18]]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:12112:78,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_deep_optional(int&, int, Key&&, Keys&& ...) const [with bool global = false; bool raw = false; sol::detail::insert_mode mode = sol::detail::none; T = sol::optional; Key = const char (&)[18]; Keys = {}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25627:62,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get_single(int, Keys&& ...) const [with bool raw = false; Ret = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[18]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25533:83,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::basic_table_core<, >::traverse_get(Keys&& ...) const [with T = sol::optional; Keys = {const char (&)[18]}; bool top_level = false; ref_t = sol::basic_reference]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:25860:40,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::tuple_get(std::index_sequence<_Ind ...>) const & [with T = sol::optional; long unsigned int ...I = {0}; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[18]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24742:39,
inlined from ‘decltype(auto) sol::table_proxy< , >::get() const & [with T = sol::optional; Table = sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&; Key = std::tuple<const char (&)[18]>]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:24847:23,
inlined from ‘sol::proxy_base< >::operator T() const [with T = sol::optional; typename std::enable_if<sol::meta::all<std::integral_constant<bool, (! std::integral_constant<bool, ((((((is_string_literal_array_of_v<T, char> || is_same_v<T, const char*>) || is_same_v<T, char>) || is_string_of_v<T, char>) || is_same_v<T, std::initializer_list >) || is_string_view_of_v<T, char>) || is_null_pointer_v)>::value)>, sol::is_proxy_primitive<typename std::remove_cv<typename std::remove_reference<Iter>::type>::type> >::value, sol::meta::enable_t>::type = sol::meta::enable_t::; Super = sol::table_proxy<sol::basic_table_core<false, sol::basic_reference >&, std::tuple<const char (&)[18]> >]’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16973:32,
inlined from ‘osrm::extractor::Sol2ScriptingEnvironment::InitContext(osrm::extractor::LuaScriptingContext&)::<lambda()>’ at /home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/src/extractor/scripting_environment_lua.cpp:671:83:
/home/madwax/devel/tmp/osrm-backend/third_party/sol2/include/sol/sol.hpp:16152:49: error: array subscript ‘const char [30][0]’ is partly outside array bounds of ‘const char [18]’ [-Werror=array-bounds=]
16152 | lua_getfield(L, tableindex, &key[0]);

Steps to reproduce

• Clone
• cmake et al

Specifications

Please provide details of your development environment.

• brand new Ubuntu 24.04 machine setup with the apt package list defined for 22.04

I get it's not a release and I don't know if you run the no breaking master/main rule.

[DennisOSRM]

Can you post the output from the cmake run? Probably an incompatibility of dependencies and/or compiler versions. At least that's the initial guess.

[madwax]

As asked for the build output:
putty.log

I think the problem is the compiler. I run into the same problem building v5.27.1 from git or downloaded source. I had a very quick poke around to fix it but somehow what I through was the fix failed due to key being something else other than a char[], I had to give up at that point.

[donno]

This looks like a duplicate of #6704, newer versions of GCC are picking up a problem in sol2 (a dependency of osrm-backend) or a GCC bug